Award watch · 14th season
| RK | Player | Pos | Team | Season | Pts | LW |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Justin Lamson | QB |  Montana State | 937 YDS7 TD80.0% CMP | 168 | 2 |
| 2 |  Ty Pennington | QB |  Northern Arizona | 1,154 YDS15 TD75.3% CMP | 147 | 6 |
| 3 |  Nate Bell | QB |  Eastern Washington | 1,002 YDS9 TD65.3% CMP | 147 | 7 |
| 4 |  Kealii Ah Yat | QB |  Montana | 612 YDS3 TD69.3% CMP | 140 | 1 |
| 5 |  Nino Iacovino | HB |  New Hampshire | 354 YDS4 TD5.3 YPC | 137 | NR |
| 6 |  Spencer Mermans | TE |  Yale | 23 REC387 YDS4 TD | 133 | 10 |
| 7 |  Dom Nankil | QB |  San Diego | 1,071 YDS10 TD60.1% CMP | 127 | 4 |
| 8 |  Beau Brungard | QB |  Youngstown State | 479 YDS3 TD80.9% CMP | 123 | 5 |
| 9 |  Dante Reno | QB | Yale | 635 YDS8 TD56.8% CMP | 120 | 3 |
Ordered by award points; LW = last week's slot.
All-Division9 Teams
First Team
| Pos | Player | Team | Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| QB | Caleb Sanchez RS SO |  Columbia | 0 YDS0 TD- CMP |
| QB | Kealii Ah Yat RS JR | Montana | 612 YDS3 TD69.3% CMP |
| HB |  Donta Whack RS SR |  Robert Morris | 109 YDS1 TD4.4 YPC |
| HB |  Eli Gillman RS SR | Montana | 50 YDS2 TD8.3 YPC |
| HB |  Quran Gossett JR | Northern Arizona | 229 YDS1 TD6.4 YPC |
| WR |  Malachi Jackson SR |  Southern | 9 REC87 YDS2 TD |
| WR |  Ian Collins RS SR |  Northern Iowa | 2 REC22 YDS0 TD |
| WR |  Sam Milligan SR |  Bucknell | 13 REC144 YDS1 TD |
| TE |  Nathan Sayle RS SO |  Penn | 0 REC0 YDS0 TD |
| LT |  Jayden Rogers RS JR | Southern | 3 PANCAKES1 SACKS ALW4 GP |
| RG |  Nikolas Engelmore RS FR | Robert Morris | 0 PANCAKES0 SACKS ALW0 GP |
| RT |  Ben Kuehnast RS SR | Northern Iowa | 7 PANCAKES1 SACKS ALW3 GP |
| LE |  Elijah Brady RS JR | Montana | 0 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| LE |  Jalen Carpenter RS SR |  Marist | 28 TKL4 TFL1 SACKS |
| DT |  Presley Titus RS SO |  Stonehill | 0 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| DT |  Jaylen Pettus RS SR | Northern Iowa | 1 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| DT |  Sean Scheck SR | San Diego | 18 TKL4 TFL1 SACKS |
| MLB |  Aiden Bergin JR | Penn | 23 TKL4 TFL1 SACKS |
| MLB |  Asher Cunningham RS JR |  Elon | 11 TKL1 TFL1 SACKS |
| MLB |  Moses Meus RS JR |  Rhode Island | 3 TKL1 TFL0 SACKS |
| RLB |  Emanuel Nazy RS SO | Columbia | 0 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| RLB |  Keyshawn Johnson SR |  UT Martin | 21 TKL4 TFL1 SACKS |
| RLB |  Max Samuel SR |  Valporaiso | 26 TKL5 TFL1 SACKS |
| CB |  Tyler Smith SR |  Charleston Southern | 15 TKL0 INT2 PD |
| CB |  Isaiah Green JR |  Portland State | 9 TKL1 INT2 PD |
| FS |  Syncere Safeeullah RS JR |  Tennessee State | 6 TKL0 INT0 PD |
| FS |  Noel Roach SR | Robert Morris | 7 TKL1 INT0 PD |
| FS |  Cam Johnson RS SR |  Stony Brook | 12 TKL0 INT2 PD |
| SS |  Lee Bruner IV JR |  Richmond | 13 TKL0 INT1 PD |
| SS |  Byron Floyd RS SR | Youngstown State | 3 TKL0 INT0 PD |
| K |  Ben Shrewsbury SR |  VMI | 7/8 FG87.5% FG%52 LNG |
| P |  Tommy Sleeman JR | Columbia | 20 PUNTS36.9 AVG6 IN 20 |
| P |  Nathaniel Wallace-Dilli RS SR |  UTRGV | 8 PUNTS37.1 AVG3 IN 20 |
Second Team
| Pos | Player | Team | Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| QB |  Byron McNair SR | Tennessee State | 793 YDS9 TD57.8% CMP |
| QB |  Champ Long RS JR |  North Carolina A&T | 531 YDS3 TD40.5% CMP |
| QB | Ty Pennington SR | Northern Arizona | 1,154 YDS15 TD75.3% CMP |
| HB |  Deion Brown RS JR |  Indiana State | 135 YDS2 TD6.4 YPC |
| HB |  Chandler Chapman SR |  Southern Illinois | 477 YDS2 TD7.2 YPC |
| HB |  Joshua Dye RS JR |  Southern Utah | 430 YDS4 TD6.1 YPC |
| HB |  Jared Rhodes RS SR |  Lindenwood | 417 YDS2 TD6.1 YPC |
| WR |  Evens Valcourt Jr. RS SR |  Miss Valley State | 0 REC0 YDS0 TD |
| WR |  Jaquan McGee SR |  Texas Southern | 8 REC62 YDS0 TD |
| WR |  Brock Montgomery JR | Tennessee State | 10 REC83 YDS2 TD |
| WR |  Gabe Nunez RS SR | Southern Utah | 9 REC99 YDS1 TD |
| TE |  Will Dixon RS SR | Rhode Island | 20 REC300 YDS3 TD |
| TE |  Max Ziebarth SR |  Illinois State | 8 REC70 YDS1 TD |
| TE |  Levi Wilkins RS SR |  Bryant | 0 REC0 YDS0 TD |
| LT |  Aden Smith JR | Bryant | 0 PANCAKES0 SACKS ALW0 GP |
| LG |  Bryan Wallace RS SO | Southern | 0 PANCAKES0 SACKS ALW0 GP |
| LG |  Seth Martin SR |  Stephen F. Austin | 4 PANCAKES1 SACKS ALW3 GP |
| C |  Misiolo Maluia SR |  West Georgia | 2 PANCAKES2 SACKS ALW3 GP |
| RG |  Jordan Lester Town SR |  Alcorn State | 8 PANCAKES2 SACKS ALW4 GP |
| RG |  Landon Roaten RS SR |  Abilene Christian | 5 PANCAKES4 SACKS ALW5 GP |
| RT |  Justin Rogers RS SR |  UAPB | 1 PANCAKES1 SACKS ALW3 GP |
| RT |  Carlos Fuentes RS SR |  Tarleton State | 12 PANCAKES1 SACKS ALW4 GP |
| RT |  Francisco Caballero SR |  Dartmouth | 5 PANCAKES0 SACKS ALW2 GP |
| LE |  Vashun Turner JR | Miss Valley State | 20 TKL5 TFL2 SACKS |
| LE |  Terrell Spruill JR | Rhode Island | 10 TKL4 TFL2 SACKS |
| LE |  Jaylyn Spencer SR |  Central Arkansas | 14 TKL5 TFL2 SACKS |
| DT |  Tyler Henry SR |  North Dakota | 14 TKL9 TFL4 SACKS |
| DT |  Kahmari Brown JR | Elon | 15 TKL5 TFL2 SACKS |
| MLB |  Cam Santee SR |  Holy Cross | 10 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| MLB |  Aidan OCallaghan RS SO |  Weber State | 0 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| RLB |  Carlo Crocetti SR | Holy Cross | 6 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| RLB |  Owen Johnson SR |  Harvard | 22 TKL1 TFL0 SACKS |
| CB |  Eric Zachery JR |  Prarie View A&M | 13 TKL2 INT7 PD |
| CB |  David Neuberger RS SR | North Dakota | 0 TKL0 INT0 PD |
| CB |  Josh Williams RS JR |  Dayton | 12 TKL1 INT5 PD |
| CB |  Ishaan Daniels JR | Weber State | 4 TKL1 INT2 PD |
| FS |  Xaden Benson JR | Harvard | 10 TKL0 INT4 PD |
| FS |  Trevell Mullen SR | Illinois State | 10 TKL0 INT2 PD |
| SS |  Nate Robinson Jr. JR | Marist | 7 TKL1 INT1 PD |
| K |  Dawson Jones RS SR |  Furman | 0/4 FG0.0% FG%0 LNG |
| P |  Jesse Ehrlich RS SR |  Cal Poly | 14 PUNTS44.5 AVG7 IN 20 |