Award watch · 1st season
| RK | Player | Pos | Team | Season | Pts | LW |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Cale McThenia | QB |  Northern Iowa | 0 YDS0 TD- CMP | 190 | 1 |
| 2 |  Drew Eason | QB |  Stonehill | 0 YDS0 TD- CMP | 170 | 2 |
| 3 |  Cam'Ron McCoy | QB |  Southern | 44 YDS0 TD60.0% CMP | 150 | 3 |
| 4 |  Lek Powell | QB |  Charleston Southern | 103 YDS0 TD44.0% CMP | 130 | 4 |
| 5 |  James Hayes | QB |  Alabama State | 0 YDS0 TD- CMP | 110 | 5 |
| 6 |  Keyondray Jones-Logan | HB |  South Dakota | 69 YDS3 TD6.3 YPC | 100 | NR |
| 7 |  Joshua Roberson | HB | Stonehill | 110 YDS0 TD5.5 YPC | 90 | 6 |
| 8 |  Trey Holly | HB | Southern | 32 YDS0 TD4.6 YPC | 80 | 7 |
| 9 |  River Lakey | HB |  Lindenwood | 4 YDS0 TD4.0 YPC | 70 | 8 |
| 10 |  Kobe Brown | WR | Southern | 3 REC46 YDS0 TD | 60 | 9 |
Ordered by award points; LW = last week's slot.
All-CAA Teams
First Team
| Pos | Player | Team | Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| HB | Joshua Roberson JR | Stonehill | 110 YDS0 TD5.5 YPC |
| HB |  Ryan Kennedy JR |  Villanova | 0 YDS0 TD- YPC |
| WR |  Jaaden Simpkins JR | Stonehill | 3 REC20 YDS0 TD |
| WR |  Noah Shimko FR |  Maine | 0 REC0 YDS0 TD |
| WR |  Jeremiah Cunningham FR |  Southeast Missouri St | 0 REC0 YDS0 TD |
| WR |  Tyler Burbatsky FR |  Stony Brook | 0 REC0 YDS0 TD |
| TE |  Brendan Hester FR |  Elon | 0 REC0 YDS0 TD |
| LT |  Lotanna Onyekaba JR | Stonehill | 3 PANCAKES1 SACKS ALW1 GP |
| C |  Keegan Shackford SR |  William & Mary | 2 PANCAKES0 SACKS ALW1 GP |
| RG |  Dan O'Leary FR | Maine | 0 PANCAKES0 SACKS ALW0 GP |
| RT |  Tyler Klambara SO |  UAlbany | 3 PANCAKES0 SACKS ALW1 GP |
| LE |  Franco Milano SR | Stony Brook | 12 TKL2 TFL0 SACKS |
| RE |  Senquavious Alsobrooks JR | Elon | 0 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| DT |  PJ Williams SR | Stonehill | 3 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| DT |  Kyle Reviello JR | William & Mary | 1 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| LLB |  Alfred Thomas SO |  Towson | 1 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| MLB |  Brock Butler SR | Stonehill | 0 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| RLB |  Dillon Dunathan SO | UAlbany | 0 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| CB |  Na'Cire Christmas JR | Maine | 0 TKL0 INT0 PD |
| CB |  Zech Pratt JR | Lindenwood | 3 TKL0 INT0 PD |
| FS |  Ngianni Cerisier SR | Maine | 0 TKL0 INT0 PD |
| SS |  Jordan Greenhow SR | William & Mary | 2 TKL0 INT0 PD |
| K |  Enda Kirby SR | Stony Brook | 2/2 FG100.0% FG%40 LNG |
| P |  Legend Robinson JR | Lindenwood | 5 PUNTS41.0 AVG1 IN 20 |
Second Team
| Pos | Player | Team | Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| HB |  Alex Jreige JR | UAlbany | 85 YDS1 TD6.1 YPC |
| HB |  JT Smith JR |  North Carolina A&T | 32 YDS0 TD5.3 YPC |
| HB |  Zay Perkins SR | Towson | 0 YDS0 TD- YPC |
| WR |  Thomas Brown SR | North Carolina A&T | 1 REC32 YDS0 TD |
| WR |  Cortez Lane SO | North Carolina A&T | 3 REC37 YDS0 TD |
| WR |  Ryan Boyd FR | Lindenwood | 3 REC26 YDS0 TD |
| WR |  John Anthony JR | Lindenwood | 0 REC0 YDS0 TD |
| TE |  Sean Welde FR | Villanova | 4 REC27 YDS0 TD |
| LT |  Nate Cole FR | UAlbany | 3 PANCAKES1 SACKS ALW1 GP |
| LG |  Tony Failla JR | Lindenwood | 0 PANCAKES0 SACKS ALW0 GP |
| C |  Luis Gastelum JR | UAlbany | 0 PANCAKES0 SACKS ALW0 GP |
| RG |  Connor Ivey SR | Stonehill | 0 PANCAKES0 SACKS ALW0 GP |
| RT |  Gabe Navarro SO | North Carolina A&T | 1 PANCAKES0 SACKS ALW1 GP |
| LE |  Brady Echols FR | William & Mary | 3 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| RE |  Bryce Purnell SR | Maine | 0 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| DT |  Sean Stackpole SR | Stonehill | 0 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| DT |  Tosin Akinsulire JR |  Rhode Island | 4 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| LLB |  Asher Cunningham SO | Elon | 0 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| MLB |  Jayden Williams SO | North Carolina A&T | 3 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| RLB |  Jarvis Jones SO | Towson | 4 TKL0 TFL0 SACKS |
| CB |  Richard Mosley III JR | Stonehill | 3 TKL0 INT0 PD |
| CB |  Eric Gant SR | Lindenwood | 5 TKL0 INT0 PD |
| FS |  Ethan Yip SR | William & Mary | 4 TKL0 INT2 PD |
| SS |  Joseph Garcia JR | Stony Brook | 3 TKL0 INT0 PD |
| K |  Hudson Fiene JR |  Monmouth | 0/1 FG0.0% FG%0 LNG |
| P |  Randy Leavitt SR | Rhode Island | 0 PUNTS- AVG0 IN 20 |